move over APSR!

An interesting message from Christopher Zorn to the POLMETH listserve showed up at my desktop this morning.  It appears that the 2007 impact factor of the methodology-heavy journal Political Analysis, “rose from 0.917 to 2.535, an increase of 176 percent.”  That makes Political Analysis the top journal in Political Science, by-passing APSR.  Now I understand-before you get all perklempt-that JCR impact factors are a problematic measure of “impact”, have criterion validity problems, not all of the relevant jourmals are included (and there seems to be no rhyme or reason for which journals get included) and are probably not even reproducible by third parties (we’ve covered some of this ground before; here, here, and here), and all the rest, but I still wonder whether this signals some permanent substantive change in the nature of the field (i.e. the Cambridge-led “political methodology” movement has finally made-over the discipline), or whether it is just another random JCR fluctuation (and yes, AJS and ASR are still the top impact journals in the 2007 rankings for sociology).

Written by Omar

June 19, 2008 at 12:14 pm

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Quickly looking at the orgs journals (in mgt) — here’s how things changed there:

    Journal 2006 2007
    Org Sci 2.81 3.13
    AMR 4.52 4.37
    ASQ 2.45 2.91
    AMJ 3.35 5.02
    SMJ 2.63 2.83



    June 19, 2008 at 7:31 pm

  2. OK — need to add two more journals into the mix — the first one is Journal of Management Inquiry (b/c I edit for it) and the second is Industrial and Corporate Change (b/c they publish interesting stuff):

    Journal 2006 2007
    JMI 0.46 1.34
    ICC 1.08 1.33



    June 19, 2008 at 7:46 pm

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: