ok, kids, out of the pool – we need to talk about the commenting rules
Everybody get on the bench. Yes, that includes you, Ramirez. I know you have to use the bathroom, but you can hold it for a little while I talk – ok?
Alright, this is about the comment policy. Ever since we started in 2006, our policy has been to let people say whatever they want. I can’t speak for everyone, but I can speak for myself. I have always felt that intellectual life should be based on evaluating the merits of argument, not the rank of the person. So I always hate it when one guy hogs up the class discussion, or people pull back just because the speaker is a fancy chair at some big university.* That’s why we generally let most comments stand. High school students and full professors all sit at the same table.
But we occasionally edit comments or delete them. Here are the rules. Follow them and no one gets hurt:
- We delete all spam.
- We will ban commenters who obsessively repeat the same points over and over, regardless of context.
- We delete comments that are personal attacks on individuals.
- We delete comments that use profanity or sexually explicit/offesnive material.
- The Sherkat Exemption: Professor Sherkat of Southern Illinois University is exempt from Rule #4.
- Each orgtheory crew member reserves the right to delete comments as they see fit.
It’s not a hard rule, but I’ve also deleted a few comments that were nothing more than grousing. If you hate this blog, go read another one. Write your own. It’s not a required class.
I don’t censor for political opinions, genuine academic disagreements or anything else that is a real engagement with the topics we cover at orgtheory.
Agree? Good. There’s little cups of Gatorade on the table by the Pepsi machine.
* Yes, IU groupies, I’m referring to the Bobo incident.